Commentary - Winter's Bone

Thursday, May 20, 2010

If I had been born a mountain girl of the Ozarks, I would know that God didn't love me and that I was being punished for past life mistakes. Shooting and skinning squirrels for dinner, chopping wood, wearing no makeup, living in an unadorned cabin, and stepping outside to view bleakness all around me, sounds like a fate worse than death or jail.  

PFS screened the 2010 Sundance
Grand Jury Prize winning film, Winter's Bone on Wednesday night as part of the filmadelphiaEXPERIENCE Screenings series, which included a Q&A after the film with Director/Screenwriter, Debra Granik.

The film is based on Daniel Woodrell's novel of the same name; Granik and her writing partner, Anne Rosellini eagerly delved into adapting the book into a screenplay and set out to the deep hills of Missouri to film. Which actually only took 24 days to shoot, so perhaps even I could rough it for that long - Nope.  

Ree Dolly (Jennifer Lawrence) is a 17 year old girl living in the Ozarks solely caring for her two younger siblings and a mother who decided to mentally check out from this harsh existence. The father is a key figure in the film, he's out on bail, having been arrested for "Cooking Crank" aka making crystal meth. His court date is coming up and he's no where to be found; since their cabin and land was put up for collateral, if he doesn't show, they lose everything.

The set up sounds like the background to a musical, like Oliver or Les Miserable, and there are times when Ree's odyssey to locate her father is a little too deliberate - traversing the countryside, dealing with "The Law" and distant family members with fierce "gate keeper" mentality; it is a story about perseverance and survival. However, it is in no way melodramatic. It's a solid look at certain realities of life lived in this Ozark culture, and at the same time, it's an engrossing movie. Jennifer Lawrence, who I also really liked in The Burning Plain, (click link to see Tinsel & Tine's The Burning Plain commentary) took on a very challenging role, she's in just about every scene and is so terrific.

I enjoyed Debra Granik's thoughtful and detailed answers to the audience's questions at the Q&A, but transcribing it verbatim - not happening . Here are some highlights with some responses summarized:

Were the actors cast from the area?

A: The leads were cast on the coast. Then a tier of actors from Missouri, many trained in acting classes from Missouri State University, although none of them were ever in a film before. Then the last section was cast during research and location scouting, "a couple of people just crossed our path and looked so right for certain roles, that we cast them". The children that play Ree's siblings have no prior acting experience. In fact, the little girl was cast because she lived in the house where the film was shot. Originally, the script called for two brothers, but this little girl looked like she came from "this piece of earth".

How long was the pre-production period?

A: Scouting happened in increments over two years, seven trips. The first was to meet the author, he hooked us up with a few important people, a historian, musicians, a guide who could be the liaison between the film and the community. He was able to knock on doors that we wouldn't have been able to go to directly.

The actors, Jen and John Hawkes (who played Teardrop) came down a week ahead of time. Jen had to do a lot of work learning how to use the farm machinery and the squirrel skinning. John visited some bars and got recordings of people's voices in the community to learn accents. "This was a crucial part of the production, to have time before rolling to get acclimated and steeped and immersed in the groove."

How was the film received in that part of the country?

A: I was there these past four days in the Ozarks. We had four screenings- in the home base where the film was shot, Northern Arkansas and West Plain, which is the author's area. The first screening had a biased audience of people from the area and associated with the film, so they felt very proprietary and proud. The second screening was attended by the head of the Ozarks Studies department at Missouri State. He said the film got a lot right. The question came up about perpetuating a notion that Hill Country people are quicker to violence than other parts of the country. He felt this was statistically not true, but there is a tradition to handle problems outside the law; yet the legends and the lore that have grown up out of this place exceed the actual number of incidents.

Granik having spoken about the definition of Hillbilly for the last year, given that she's not one, feels it will be crucial to include in the DVD extras, "27 definitions of Hillbilly" as defined by anyone who identify themselves as one. To have people from this area put words to this term, verses the history of defining it from the outside. "At what point do you retire the Hatfield's and the McCoys?"

Q: Did you have any connection to Ozark culture before reading the story?  

A: "I did not have a relationship or connection or understanding of Ozark culture. Southern Missouri was not a place I had been to or knew about in any significant way. I think what drew me to the story is the character of Ree Dolly. I was very drawn in by this female protagonist, cared about her very quickly, cared about her struggles and her interests and aspirations. I was very curious about her. Ultimately, I wanted to see her prevail and wanted to know how she would do that and the book kept me in suspense about that. How would she get to this place where she'd be able to make a difference in her family's life and maybe stop something, stop a cycle that was ongoing in her family." 

Q: What else have you directed?  

A: I did a film prior to this call Down to the Bone, starring Vera Farmiga , so the word bone does keep popping up. If we do another one, it will be the Osteo trilogy.

Post a Comment


IFC’s TWO DAYS, ONE NIGHT will open in Philadelphai at the Ritz at the Bourse January 23rd. Marion Cotillard nominated for Best Actress in the film!

“A CAREER-HIGH PERFORMANCE BY OSCAR® WINNER MARION COTILLARD. After spending ‘Two Days, One Night’ in the company of Sandra, YOU’LL BE PUNCHING THE AIR WITH PRIDE.” –Dave Calhoun, Time Out

Whitney Movie on Lifetime Quick Review


Personally, I still maintain, what made the book(s) a guilty pleasure can't be captured in a movie, it's just not the type of story that will translate well on screen. That being said, I'll still be the first one there come Valentine's Day 2015! Here's Tinsel & Tine's Review of the Books - My Two Cents on Fifty Shades of Grey (Book / Movie)

T&T Pinterest Restaurant Spotlight: ROSA BLANCA

T&T Pinterest Restaurant Spotlight: ROSA BLANCA
Our quick look at a new favorite Center City spot ! CHECK IT OUT

Timely Pop Culture Take-Aways and Digi Trend Forecasts

Lauren DeLisa's Wrap Up/Look Ahead: Trends That Will Impact in under 2 minutes!


25 TO LIFE chronicles the story of William Brawner, a young man who kept his HIV positive status a secret for over twenty-five years. Now, William seeks redemption from his promiscuous past as he embarks on a new phase of life with his wife who is HIV Negative. We journey with William and his family as he struggles to carve out an open and honest future. 25 TO LIFE is supported by Sundance Institute, Cinereach, The GoodPitch, IFP, Firelight Media Lab, and Tribeca All Access and is the 2014 American Black Film Festival Grand Prize Jury winner. "25 to Life" Opens December 1, 2014 - World AIDS Day

Google Adsense

TT Highlights : GET ON UP

TT Highlights : GET ON UP
I know biopics often get a bad name, they can be cliched and predictable or the reverse, so creatively told that you lose the gist of the story and the heart of the intended subject. I tend to like them good or bad, from offerings like The Runaways (Cherie Currie & Joan Jett) which didn't quite hit the mark, to Ray (Ray Charles) and Walk The Line (Johnny Cash) that rightfully became critically acclaimed films. I'm just fascinated with the whole rise and fall aspect of telling life stories READ POST

What Did You Think Of: BELLE

What Did You Think Of: BELLE
#Belle is a beautifully shot film (on the Isle of Mann), the writing gives us many poignant thoughts and thought provoking dialogue. The romantic chemistry between Dido Belle and Mr. Davinier (Sam Reid) is what all us hopeless romantics look for in a movie. And Gugu Mbatha-Raw acts with such expression in her eyes, she's simply lovely (despite her unappealing name). I adore this movie! I also got such a delight every time someone referred to Dido as Miss Lindsay, as that's my last name, of course it makes me wonder, could I be a long, long lost relation?...READ MORE


Those that could fit in anywhere are called Divergents, they are considered dangerous because they can't be controlled and molded into one way of thinking. Those that don't fit in anywhere are called Faction-less and they live a miserable, homeless existence, but nobody's much worried about them. I'm thinking, if you choose a faction based on your own free will, wouldn't that automatically make you a Divergent?...READ MORE

What did you think of: I Origins

What did you think of:  I Origins
The movie theorizes that eyes are like snowflakes, no two are the same. So if you were to find a match in the eye scanning database (which actually exists) of someone who's already dead, then it begs the question, would that be a glitch in the system? Or has that person returned for a second life, seeing things anew through their old eyes?READ MORE

Did You See: Boyhood

Did You See: Boyhood
How I wish I could have filmed the last 12-15 years of my life, because I swear it often feels like I've done nothing, barely enjoyed myself, have made no progress, can't think of a single anecdote to tell and the small significant moments of in-significances, just don't seem to be stored in my brain. But if I could look back at even one day of each year, I'm sure I would be so much happier with who I am, what I've experienced and how far I've come...READ POST

Recent post: The Trip to Italy

Recent post: The Trip to Italy
Absolutely nothing! But somehow the juxtaposition of so much pop-culture fodder, Steve Coogan and Rob Brydon's semi-autobiographical characters set against travel porn, makes The Trip to Italy a randomly amusing and thoroughly breathtaking flick.READ MORE


I'm sure every decade has a movie that you love because you're balling your eyes out; however, I truly think Shailene Woodley and Ansel Elgort in #TFIOS could be what Ali McGraw and Ryan O'Neal were to Love Story for audiences in 1970.READ MORE

Philly Event Coverage: Cake Competition Recap

Philly Event Coverage: Cake Competition Recap
If you read this blog frequently, you know I mention cake quite a lot. I'm a self-confessed cake-aholic, but I'm also a cake snob. I don't want just anything with icing on it, and in fact, it is crucial that the icing not be too sweet, too thick and preferably only on top. It's difficult to put into words what constitutes good cake, it's like describing a sunset or an orgasm, you just know it when you're in the moment of it...READ MORE

Think Like A Man Too Philly Interview: Meagan Good & Michael Ealy

Think Like A Man Too Philly Interview: Meagan Good & Michael Ealy
Got a chance to not only be among the media photogs at the "Think Like A Man Too" red carpet, but I also got to interview Meagan Good and Michael Ealy SEE POST

Zach Braff's: Wish I Was Here

Zach Braff's: Wish I Was Here
When a filmmaker is prolific, like a Steven Soderbergh before his "retirement", we tend to allow each movie to stand on its own merit; but when the filmmaker does one movie and then waits 10 years to do another, it's impossible not to compare it to the first offering. Thus, I suppose Wish I Was Here was going to have to be truly, truly brilliant to keep people from saying - it's no Garden State. T &T's LAMB Score: 3 outta 5 READ FULL POST

Philadelphia Magazine » Blog » Foobooz

15 Top Food in Film Flicks

15 Top Food in Film Flicks
Cozy Quilt of Food Movies, we'll add more patches as T &T discovers more films where food plays the biggest "roll"


Large Association of Movie Blogs

Tinsel & Tine was nominated for a VBA



group of 10,000 women bloggers dedicated to supporting one another by leaving comments

Women Online

The Blogstress Network

The Blogstress Network
Female Bloggers Unite

Contributor from 2010 - 2012

Listed on

Movie & Film Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory Add website

About This Blog

is about discovering what I find pleasing in screening & eating - in case you missed it, the name is a play on Tinseltown using the Tines of a Fork.

Feel free to send me info on a film or new restaurant you'd like me to highlight.

Will there ever be a cap on movie prices?

Will we one day pay $20 a pop?

Why don't we pay on a scale?

A crap movie like everything Adam Sandler has ever done should cost about $4.50.
Big action movies like"Lord of the Rings", "Iron Man," "Transformers" are worth $10.
Woody Allen movie or something like "Silver Linings Playbook" $6-$7.
A chick flick or light comedy $5.75 and most Indie Films $5.25.

You could even do it by seasons - all summer block busters from May to August - $10
Sept - November 15th $3.50 - $4
Back to $10 for Thanksgiving and Christmas etc...

Or you can do it by A Actors ($9 - $10), B Actors ($6 - $7) TV actors on the big screen ($3.50 - $4)

Surely I'm not the first person to realize this makes sense. Has it been voted on in the Motion Picture Industry and then vetoed? If so, why?

Share it

Camera Tips


  © Blogger template On The Road by 2009

Back to TOP